Compare King

Milk Bar

Visit Site

Watch a video review of this product

Pros & Cons

Cakes have a quirky, colorful aesthetic

Known for its Milk Bar Pie, an original creation

Cereal-flavored ice cream is fun to try

Doesn't ship for free, unlike many other bakeries

Dessert Types

Cakes, cake truffles, cookies, pies, ice cream

Shipping

Shipping is always $15.

Bakery Location

Milk Bar has locations in New York City, Los Angeles, Washington DC, Boston, and Toronto.

Milk Bar Full Review

Carlo's Bakery

Visit Site

Watch a video review of this product

Pros & Cons

Has custom cakes for all occasions

This is the bakery from the show Cake Boss, which makes it extra fun to order from

Doesn't offer vegan or gluten-free options

Dessert Types

Cakes, pre-sliced cake, pastries, cookies, pizza, coffee pods

Shipping

Most products ship for free.

Bakery Location

Carlo's Bakery has locations in Santa Monica, Las Vegas, Bloomington, San Antonio, McAllen, Orlando, and Toronto, as well as six locations in the Northeast U.S.

Carlo's Bakery Full Review

Ovenly

Visit Site

Watch a video review of this product

Pros & Cons

Offers a Cake of the Month Club that sends a new cake flavor each month

Cakes come in unique flavors like Lemon Lavender and Pistachio Cardamom

Not all the desserts are available for nationwide delivery

Dessert Types

Cakes, cookies and bars, breakfast loaves

Shipping

Most products ship for free.

Bakery Location

There are three Ovenly locations in Brooklyn.

Ovenly Full Review

Magnolia Bakery

Visit Site

Watch a video review of this product

Pros & Cons

Users can choose to add an inscription to cakes

Well-known for its banana pudding, a tasty alternative to baked goods

Limited selection of products that ship nationwide

Dessert Types

Cakes, cupcakes, banana pudding, cookies and bars

Shipping

Most products ship for free.

Bakery Location

There are seven locations in New York City, plus one store in Los Angeles and one in Chicago.

Magnolia Bakery Full Review

We Take the Cake

Visit Site

Watch a video review of this product

Pros & Cons

Full-size and mini Bundt cakes are an elegant alternative to traditional birthday cakes

Layer cakes are beautifully decorated, so they're perfect for fancy occasions

Cakes only come in one size (six inches)

Dessert Types

Layer cakes, Bundt cakes, cupcakes

Shipping

Most products ship for free.

Bakery Location

We Take the Cake is located in Fort Lauderdale.

We Take the Cake Full Review

Cake Delivery