Compare King

Progressive

Check Price

Watch a video review of this product

Pros & Cons

Getting a quote is very simple, can design policies to fit a price

Offers policies for non-car vehicles like RVs and golf carts

Offers coverage for rideshare drivers

Below-average customer satisfaction and claims payout

Not every coverage is available in every state

Basic Coverages

Liability, comprehensive, collision, uninsured motorist, and medical payments

Optional Coverages

Gap insurance, rental reimbursement, custom parts and equipment, rideshare, and roadside assistance

Discounts

Multi-policy, multi-car, continuous insurance, safe driver, teen driver, good student, distant student, homeowner, various discounts for using the online portal

Progressive Full Review

Amica

Check Price

Watch a video review of this product

Pros & Cons

Offers a wide range of coverages

Among the best in terms of customer satisfaction

Provides free lock and air bag replacement, as well as free glass repair

Some coverages are left out of the basic plan

Not available in Hawaii

Basic Coverages

Liability, property damage, uninsured motorist, and personal injury protection

Optional Coverages

Medical payments, comprehensive, collision, gap insurance, glass, roadside assistance, rental reimbursement, accident forgiveness, new car replacement, prestige rentals

Discounts

Loyalty, bundling, multi-car, homeowner, good student, distant student, claims-free, driver's ed, car safety features, advance payment, autopay, and paperless

Amica Full Review

Geico

Check Price

Watch a video review of this product

Pros & Cons

Usually cheaper than other brands

Offers discounts for military and military dependents

Can insure American cars driving in Canada or Mexico

Below-average claim satisfaction

Can be hard to access customer service

Basic Coverages

Liability, comprehensive, collision, uninsured motorist, personal injury protection, and medical payments

Optional Coverages

Roadside assistance, mechanical breakdown, rideshare, rental reimbursement

Discounts

Multi-policy, multi-car, new vehicle, good student, driver's ed, military, emergency deployment, federal employee, and safety features

Geico Full Review

Allstate

Check Price

Watch a video review of this product

Pros & Cons

Offers accident forgiveness and safe driving bonuses

Offers pay-by-the-mile auto insurance

Lots of discounts for younger drivers

Tends to be expensive

Above-average amount of customer complaints

Basic Coverages

Liability, comprehensive, collision, uninsured motorist, and personal injury protection

Optional Coverages

Gap insurance, rental reimbursement, roadside assistance, new car replacement, and glass

Discounts

Multi-policy, loyalty, new car, good student, safe driver, car safety features, advance pay, autopay, and paperless

Allstate Full Review

State Farm

Check Price

Watch a video review of this product

Pros & Cons

The largest auto insurer in America

High customer satisfaction

Good rental car and travel expenses coverage

Premiums can be higher than competitors

Optional coverages are a bit sparse

Basic Coverages

Liability, comprehensive, collision, uninsured motorist, medical payments

Optional Coverages

Rental reimbursement, travel payment, roadside assistance, rideshare

Discounts

Loyalty, multi-policy, multi-car, accident-free, claims-free, good student, distant student, safe driver, and driver's ed

State Farm Full Review

Car Insurance