Compare King

THE KING'S CHOICE

Vremi Large Ice Cube Trays

$14.47from Amazon

5k+ Customer Reviews

Pros & Cons

Hard plastic lids make it easy to stack the trays

Trays' compact size makes them perfect for mini fridges

Extra large cubes last a long time

Lid doesn't create a watertight seal

There's no overflow lip, so each section has to be filled individually

Material

Silicone with plastic lid

Trays per pack

Two

Cubes per tray

Eight

Price History

Create Price Alert

Vremi Large Ice Cube Trays Full Review

EASIEST TO USE

OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray

$9.99from Amazon

4k+ Customer Reviews

Pros & Cons

Silicone lid seals in water and keeps ice from absorbing odors

Cubes have a rounded bottom, so they're easy to remove

Trays can be placed at angles without leaking

Getting extra water out can be annoying and messy

Cubes are fairly small

Material

Plastic with silicone lid

Trays per pack

One

Cubes per tray

Fourteen

Price History

Create Price Alert

OXO Good Grips Ice Cube Tray Full Review

AiBast Ice Trays

$16.99from Amazon

1k+ Customer Reviews

Pros & Cons

Versatile trays can also be used as dessert molds

Comes with a small funnel and silicone measuring cup

Cubes come out easily

Trays are pretty flimsy, so they can be hard to carry to the freezer

Lids don't fit on tightly

Material

Silicone with plastic lid

Trays per pack

Three

Cubes per tray

Six (round), six (square), thirty-seven (honeycomb)

Price History

Create Price Alert

AiBast Ice Trays Full Review

MOST POPULAR

DOQAUS Ice Cube Trays

$11.99from Amazon

7k+ Customer Reviews

Pros & Cons

Trays are designed to stack, and they're not bulky

Soft silicone bottoms make it easy to pop ice cubes out

More structure than most silicone molds

Smaller than standard ice cube trays

Plastic tends to crack when trays are twisted

Material

Silicone and plastic with plastic lid

Trays per pack

Four

Cubes per tray

Fourteen

Price History

Create Price Alert

DOQAUS Ice Cube Trays Full Review

BEST VALUE

Rubbermaid Easy Release Ice Cube Trays

$6.99from Amazon

3k+ Customer Reviews

Pros & Cons

Long-lasting plastic

Ice cubes come out cleanly and easily

Trays are stackable

More shallow than standard ice cube trays

Can be difficult to fill; splashes water

Material

Plastic

Trays per pack

Two

Cubes per tray

Sixteen

Price History

Create Price Alert

Rubbermaid Easy Release Ice Cube Trays Full Review